Seafood markets

Fisherman's Island

4.3 1,179 reviews Closed 6659 S Wentworth Ave, Chicago, IL 60621, United States

Discover this place

Fisherman's Island, nestled at 6659 S Wentworth Ave in Chicago, IL, stands out as a premier seafood market that has captured the hearts of many. Patrons rave about the delectable freshness of the seafood, often noting the irresistible aroma reminiscent of butter and the ocean. Genesis Hernandez captures the essence of the experience, highlighting how the seafood is both soft and fresh, making for a truly enjoyable meal. While the food is frequently praised, customer service seems to be hit or miss. Lil Blaq Beauty commends the friendly staff and emphasizes the wide variety of seafood made fresh to order, though a bit of waiting is required. Conversely, LaTasha Morris reports a lack of organization, which detracts from the overall experience. Despite mixed reviews on service, the culinary delights remain the focal point. Amy-Theresa Billups recalls her joy upon returning, finding the crab meat pristine and effortless to extract from its shell. Lakeisha Morris shares her enthusiasm for the menu, deeming it a delicious way to welcome the New Year, expressing a desire to make it a tradition. Overall, Fisherman's Island is where quality seafood shines, leaving diners eager to return for more, despite occasional service hiccups. It's an outing that promises a feast of flavor and freshness that any seafood lover would cherish.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery

Amenities

Restroom

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Fisherman's Island before visiting.

Reviews for Fisherman's Island

4.3

1,179 reviews

100%

34%

16%

11%

Review highlights

Based on 1,179 reviews

Fisherman's Island is widely appreciated for its fresh, flavorful seafood that consistently delights customers with buttery, tender textures and a variety of well-seasoned dishes. The market's made-to-order approach emphasizes quality, although it may result in wait times. Many patrons praise the delicious taste and freshness, making it a favored destination for seafood enthusiasts. However, feedback regarding customer service is mixed, with some noting issues around organization and professionalism. Despite this, the overall dining experience remains positive, driven by the quality of the seafood and the friendly atmosphere. Fisherman's Island has established itself as a go-to spot for those seeking authentic, satisfying seafood in Chicago.

genesis Hernandez

May 19, 2025

I’ve gone here about 4 times and ngl it’s sooo good I’ve never had sea food that just smells like straight butter and the sea food so soft and fresh!

Lil Blaq Beauty

May 12, 2025

Nice friendly staff, with a great variety of seafood. It's made fresh to order so prepare yourself to wait for your food!! They have a Nice variety of seasonings for the seafood also. The overall experience of their food it's delicious.

LaTasha Morris

Apr 20, 2025

The customer service sucks, but our food was delicious! They are so unorganized and unprofessional.

Amy-Theresa Billups

Mar 27, 2025

So I was in the area and had been having a seafood platter on the brain for a few weeks. The Fisherman's Island that is closer to where I live never answers the phone. So I made my way to this location. They never disappoint!! Everything was made fresh and tasted just as amazing as I remembered. The meat slid out of the crab shells beautifully!!! I will definitely be returning!!

Lakeisha Morris

Mar 22, 2025

Totally delicious! A great way to bring in the New year It has became my new Tradition Skip the Black-eyed peas ...

Vanity Johnson

Mar 07, 2025

Love the food at this place. I wish they had more menu's. They don't fry food, but they do a great job of steaming it. I try to get something new every time I order.

Sasha LoveLess`

Feb 18, 2025

Love this location the Cajun flavor a hit I even had the tbone steak was good I didn't get a pic but everything on the link they cook for a 1 Bomb

Ikeda Bowman

Feb 07, 2025

I always get a #1 with a pound of shrimp and extra broccoli. I just hate this location because there's never anywhere to park. The food is always on point. Never had a problem here.